Antofagasta court rejects Coyo challenge to Codelco-SQM lithium pact, for now
Coyo argued SQM was selected without a public tender, putting the structure of Chile’s state-led lithium strategy under scrutiny.

Why it matters: The ruling keeps Chile’s state-backed lithium partnership on track while leaving future consultation and environmental approvals unresolved.
3-member panel — two judges and an integrating lawyer sat in the Second Chamber.
Unanimous ruling — the court rejected the petition without costs.
Decree Law No. 1,350 and Constitution Article 19(21) — provisions cited in assessing Codelco’s tender obligations.
The Antofagasta Appeals Court rejected a protective action brought by the Atacameña de Coyo Community against the agreement between Codelco and SQM to advance Chile’s National Lithium Strategy. The Second Chamber found that signing the pact did not, by itself, constitute an unlawful or arbitrary act threatening the constitutional rights cited by the community.
The decision was limited to the agreement’s current scope. The court characterized it as a legal and commercial framework for the companies to undertake future mining-related activities through a joint company—not as authorization to intervene in the Salar de Atacama or to begin environmental permitting.
The ruling does not authorize work on the salt flat
The court said the actions challenged did not amount to an intervention requiring Indigenous consultation at this stage. It described the agreement as covering potential mining, production, commercial, community and environmental development in the Salar, rather than granting immediate permission for new activity there.
That distinction leaves future steps open. The ruling assessed the signing of the agreement, not a physical intervention in the territory or the processing of environmental permits. It therefore does not decide whether consultation or other authorizations will be required if the companies move toward activities on the salt flat.
The Second Chamber comprised ministers Virginia Soublette Miranda and Juan Opazo Lagos, along with integrating lawyer Marcelo Díaz Sanhueza. Its decision was unanimous.
Court says Codelco was not required to tender for a partner
Coyo also challenged SQM’s selection without a public tender. The court found no breach, citing the framework governing Codelco’s organization, administration and mining activities under Decree Law No. 1,350 and Article 19(21) of Chile’s Constitution. It concluded that the state-owned company was not required to hold a tender to select a private partner.
As context, the ruling noted that Codelco and SQM have existing contracts and that SQM already operates in the Salar de Atacama. The court’s conclusion addressed the tender objection in the case; it did not grant new operating rights or environmental approvals through the partnership agreement.
Community action dismissed without costs
The action was filed by Gabriel Alonso Muñoz Muñoz on behalf of the Atacameña de Coyo Community against Codelco and the Production Development Corporation (Corfo). The challenged partnership agreement was signed by Codelco and SQM.
The court found no disturbance or threat to the constitutional guarantees invoked that could be attributed to the pact’s signing. It dismissed the action without costs, while leaving any requirements tied to future activities to be addressed at the relevant stage.
More in Critical Minerals
BYD and Tsingshan abandon US$523m Chile lithium plans as Corfo seeks a replacement
Chile offered preferred SQM lithium pricing through 2030 to attract battery-material makers; a new Albemarle allocation is the next test.
BLM advances Century Lithium’s Angel Island review, but mine approval remains ahead
Nevada’s proposed open pit, processing plant and water infrastructure are all within the scope of the federal environmental review.
Germany courts Australia’s critical minerals as a strategic stockpile gap persists
Eighteen German companies attended IMARC, but the supply-security effort also hinges on financing, procurement and who carries the risk.



