Chile orders Alcaparrosa closure, but the 2022 collapse is only part of the case
The mine had been suspended since July 2022, but the court's findings reach into the Copiapó River aquifer and Tierra Amarilla.

Why it matters: The ruling expands Alcaparrosa's liability beyond stabilising a mine collapse to repairing damage to a groundwater system that supports communities and ecosystems.
5 September 2025 — date of the First Environmental Court judgment.
SHAC 3, 4 and 5 — groundwater sectors included in the required aquifer diagnosis.
140,000–150,000 tonnes — copper production Lundin Mining projected for Candelaria in 2025.
Chile's First Environmental Court ordered the permanent closure of Mina Alcaparrosa and required Compañía Contractual Minera Ojos del Salado (MINOSAL) to carry out an environmental repair plan, finding that mining activity caused permanent damage to the Copiapó River aquifer. The judgment, issued on 5 September 2025 in a case brought by the State Defence Council, said the effects extended beyond the subsidence recorded in July 2022.
The court found that mining created a hydraulic connection between the mine and the aquifer, causing groundwater depletion, changes in flows and changes in water quality. It said the damage affected aquifer functions that support ecosystem services in the municipality of Tierra Amarilla.
Repair plan covers the aquifer as well as the subsidence
MINOSAL must close the mine, fill the mining subsidence and prepare an environmental diagnosis of the aquifer in Common Hydrogeological Use Sectors (SHAC) 3, 4 and 5. The plan also requires monitoring of the walls and seals built at the site.
Repair and compensation measures include infiltration ponds to support water recharge, the transfer and restriction of water rights, and improvements to rural sanitation infrastructure in Tierra Amarilla. MINOSAL must submit annual reports to the court and share progress with local communities.
Alamiro Alfaro, the court's presiding minister, said the judgment found permanent damage to both the structure and functions of the aquifer. The measures therefore extend beyond filling or stabilising the subsidence to include monitoring the water system and works intended to improve water security.
Separate opinions address responsibility and water governance
In an individual opinion, Minister Sandra Álvarez said MINOSAL's conduct amounted to eventual intent rather than negligence. She argued that the company knew the area was hydrogeologically fragile and nevertheless persisted with over-exploitation of the deposit. That view was hers and was not the court's collective finding.
Minister Marcelo Hernández described the aquifer damage as “critical” and proposed community participation in environmental governance, alongside a pilot water-reinjection project. The judgment also accepted Lundin Mining SpA's defence that it was not the proper party to the claim, and did not order it to pay. It recommended that parent company Lundin Mining Corporation strengthen its environmental oversight standards and practices.
Alcaparrosa had been suspended since 2022
Alcaparrosa operations had been suspended since the July 2022 incident. Lundin Mining said the mine's reserves were removed from its reserve statement at that time and excluded from later production estimates. The company said the ruling did not affect Candelaria, for which it projected 2025 copper production of 140,000 to 150,000 tonnes.
Lundin said it had cooperated with authorities during their investigations, providing monitoring technology, studies and experts on subsidence stability. The company said it would work with authorities and other stakeholders to clarify the remediation measures and their timing, while evaluating its next steps.
More in Resources
Tin sales rise 72% as LME stocks shrink, while global data remain incomplete
Production, smelting and sales all moved higher, but the reported figures leave key parts of the market balance unclear.
Tintina starts 40,000m at Dos Amigos, but feasibility needs more than drilling
A move straight from preliminary assessment to feasibility puts resource classification, engineering and permitting on overlapping schedules.
Endeavour Silver's Pitarrilla study prices a US$585M build before key permit
The 18-year underground model uses US$50 silver, but its returns change materially across the study's sensitivity cases.



